by Red V Four on Sun May 31, 2009 1:38 pm
You haven't mentioned it as such, but is the 'changed' battery a brand new one? If the bike started easily when you 'jumped' it from the car, then it could point to the battery. The battery may be able to illuminate the lights OK, but it may not have the 'cranking power' to turn over the engine fast enough to start the bike. Starting draws a lot of current, so if the battery is suspect, it may not be able to deliver enough, whilst being able to work lights etc.
If you have a multimeter, check the battery's voltage. It should be 12.5V+, but even then, an old battery may give this, yet not have enough power to start the bike. If it is a brand new battery, then it does sound rather odd. You would notice the difference a new battery makes if the old one is getting a bit tired.
Also, it sounds like the ignition switch is getting a bit worn, but it can't be the cause of your problem if you do get the starter to work, albeit not very well.